Midstate Mutual

Payment: 1-607-326-4141

Claim: 1-607-326-4141

Erie & Niagara

Payment: 1-800-694-8271

Claim:

  • Office Hours: 1-800-782-0154
  • Nights/Weekends: 1-800-556-5802
Dryden Mutual 

Allstate Insurance Company

Payment: 1-800-ALLSTATE (1-800-255-7828)

Claim: 1-800-ALLSTATE (1-800-255-7828)

ONLINE SERVICES


Payment: 1-800-232-9118

Claim: 1-800-232-9118

Ontario Insurance Company

Payment: 1-800-365-4999

Claim: 1-800-365-4999

ShelterPoint Life

Payment: 1-800-331-6053

Claim: 1-800-331-6053

CNA Surety

Many of our companies allow you to make premium payments 24/7 by telephone and/or online. 

To file a claim, please contact us during normal business hours. Carthage Office 315.493.2110 or 800.924.4114. Canton Office 315.386.3403. Alternatively, many of our companies have 24/7 call centers, emergency phone numbers and/or online claim reporting capabilities. If you have an after hours emergency, please call 315.493.2110 and listen to the prompts.

MORE INFORMATION:
Carthage - Office Hours Monday-Friday 8:30am-4:30pm     • Canton - Office Hours Monday-Friday 7:00am-3:00pm
After Hours Emergency Service Call 315.493.2110

Claim:

  • Personal Lines: 1-800-527-3907
  • Auto: 1-800-274-7865

Foremost Insurance Group

Payment: 1-800-462-2123

Claim: 1-800-325-1088

Merchants Insurance Group

Hagerty Insurance

Genesee Patrons

Payment: 1-800-724-1648

Claim: 1-800-724-1648

Utica National

Payment: 1-800-343-6496

Claim: 1-800-343-6496

Payment: 1-888-891-0267

Claim: 1-800-421-3535

Wayne Cooperative

Payment: 1-877-922-9701

Claim: 1-877-922-9701

Payment: 1-800-462-1077

Claim: 1-888-644-6680

May 2021 Update:  Our offices are open, but please wear a mask and observe social distancing.   Please do not enter our offices if you are feeling unwell or have a fever.  If you prefer, most of our services are available by phone or e-mail.  We appreciate your cooperation and understanding.

Fuller Insurance Agency logo

Payment: 1-800-826-8520

Claim: 1-800-826-8520

Payment/Claim: 1-800-234-9876


Facebook Messenger Logo that says Message Us on Facebook

Payment: 1-800-234-6926

Claim: 1-800-234-6926

Midrox Insurance

Payment: 1-888-723-3260

Claim: 1-800-332-3226

Safeco Insurance

Philadelphia Insurance

National General Insurance

Payment:

  • Personal Lines: 1-800-532-4221
  • Auto:  1-888-888-0080

Payment: 1-607-965-8211

Claim: 1-607-965-8211

NYCM Insurance

Payment: 1-800-842-5075

Claim: 1-800-252-4633

Payment: 1-877-438-7459

Claim: 1-800-765-9749

Accessibility

Travelers

Progressive

Otsego Mutual

Payment: 1-800-598-8422

Claim: 1-800-216-1420

Nationwide/Harleysville

Payment: 1-800-776-4737

Claim: 1-800-776-4737