Payment 800-458-0811
Claims  800-367-3743

Payment: 1-888-891-0267

Claim: 1-800-421-3535


Payment: 1-800-343-6496

Claim: 1-800-343-6496

Payment: 1-800-694-8271


  • Office Hours: 1-800-782-0154
  • Nights/Weekends: 1-800-556-5802
Dryden Mutual 

Allstate Insurance Company

Payment: 1-800-ALLSTATE (1-800-255-7828)

Claim: 1-800-ALLSTATE (1-800-255-7828)


Payment: 1-877-922-9701

Claim: 1-877-922-9701

Hagerty Insurance

Payment: 1-800-365-4999

Claim: 1-800-365-4999

ShelterPoint Life

Payment: 1-800-331-6053

Claim: 1-800-331-6053

CNA Surety

Many of our companies allow you to make premium payments 24/7 by telephone and/or online. 

To file a claim, please contact us during normal business hours. Carthage Office 315.493.2110 or 800.924.4114. Canton Office 315.386.3403. Alternatively, many of our companies have 24/7 call centers, emergency phone numbers and/or online claim reporting capabilities. If you have an after hours emergency, please call 315.493.2110 and listen to the prompts.

Payment: 1-607-965-8211

Claim: 1-607-965-8211

Otsego Mutual

Payment 800-458-0811 Option 4
Claims  800-367-3743

Erie & Niagara

Genesee Patrons


  • Personal Lines: 1-800-532-4221
  • Auto:  1-888-888-0080

Foremost Insurance Group

Payment: 1-800-234-6926

Claim: 1-800-234-6926

NYCM Insurance

Merchants Insurance Group

Payment: 1-800-462-2123

Claim: 1-800-325-1088

Payment: 1-888-723-3260

Claim: 1-800-332-3226

Ontario Insurance Company

Midrox Insurance

Payment: 1-607-326-4141

Claim: 1-607-326-4141

Payment: 1-800-826-8520

Claim: 1-800-826-8520

Fuller Insurance Agency logo ​strives to ensure that its website is made easier to use and more accessible for people with disabilities, with the strong belief that every person has the right to live with dignity, equality, comfort and independence. makes available the UserWay Website Accessibility Widget that is powered by a dedicated accessibility server.  If you are experiencing difficulty with any content on or require assistance with any part of our site, please contact us during normal business hours and we will be happy to assist.

Located in Carthage, NY and Canton, NY.  Licensed to transact business in New York State.  Our primary marketing territory is Jefferson County, Lewis County and St. Lawrence County including Watertown, NY, Fort Drum, NY, Lowville, NY, Gouverneur, NY, Potsdam, NY, Massena, NY, Ogdensburg, NY and the North Country.  We also serve throughout Upstate New York including Syracuse, NY, Oswego, NY, Utica, NY, Rome, NY, Rochester, NY and Plattsburgh, NY.


© 2021 Fuller Insurance Agency, Inc.   All Right Reserved  |  Privacy Statement  |  Disclaimer

CARTHAGE OFFICE:  110 S. SCHOOL ST., CARTHAGE, NY  |  315-493-2110  •  CANTON OFFICE:  10 COURT ST., CANTON, NY  |  315-386-3403

Wayne Cooperative

Philadelphia Insurance


Utica National

Payment: 1-877-438-7459

Claim: 1-800-765-9749

National General Insurance

Facebook Messenger Logo that says Message Us on Facebook

Erie Insurance Group

Safeco Insurance

Midstate Mutual

Payment: 1-800-776-4737

Claim: 1-800-776-4737


Payment: 1-800-842-5075

Claim: 1-800-252-4633



  • Personal Lines: 1-800-527-3907
  • Auto: 1-800-274-7865

Payment: 1-800-232-9118

Claim: 1-800-232-9118

Payment: 1-800-724-1648

Claim: 1-800-724-1648

Payment: 1-800-462-1077

Claim: 1-888-644-6680

Payment: 1-800-598-8422

Claim: 1-800-216-1420